15 Best WordPress Popup Plugins for 2025 (Conversion Tested & Ranked)

Anne McClain Jr.

November 18, 2025•17 minute read

The best WordPress popup plugins for 2025 are OptinMonster (starting at $21/month), Popup Maker (free with premium options), and TrustPulse ($9-50/month). These WordPress popup plugins can increase your conversion rates by 15-300% and help you capture abandoning visitors before they leave your site.

Table of Contents

Website visitors spend just 15 seconds on average before deciding to leave. When 70% of your traffic leaves without converting, WordPress popup plugins become your last chance to turn browsers into subscribers, customers, or leads.

Content Roadmap

What You’ll Master:

Which popup plugins deliver the highest conversion rates for different business types
How to choose between free and premium options based on your specific traffic volume
Advanced targeting strategies that can triple your lead capture rates
Integration setups that work seamlessly with your existing email marketing tools
Common popup mistakes that actually hurt conversions (and how to avoid them)

Essential Details:

Time needed: 2-3 hours for complete setup and optimization
Technical skill level: Beginner-friendly with step-by-step guidance
What you need: WordPress site, email marketing service, basic design sense
Expected results: 50-300% increase in lead capture within 30 days

Why Smart Popup Strategy Matters in 2025

Popup performance affects everything from email list growth to revenue generation. Social proof notifications alone can boost store conversions by up to 15%, and exit-intent technology is non-negotiable for capturing abandoning visitors.

Think of your website like a physical store – if customers are walking toward the exit, you’d want one last chance to offer them something valuable. A poorly-timed popup means lost forever, but strategic popups create these critical conversion opportunities:

Revenue Recovery: Exit-intent popups can recover 10-15% of abandoning visitors
List Building: Welcome mats can increase email signups by 600-800%
Customer Retention: Targeted offers keep visitors engaged longer
Social Proof: Real-time notifications create urgency and trust

The Good News: Modern WordPress popup plugins solve all these problems while often costing less than hiring a single freelance designer.

Top 15 WordPress Popup Plugins (Ranked by Performance)

1. OptinMonster – The Conversion Powerhouse

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 785% | Starting Price: $21/month

Why OptinMonster ranks #1 despite higher pricing: It consistently delivers the highest conversion rates across all industries. The Basic plan starts at $21/month, though advanced tools like countdown timers and exit-intent popups require the Pro plan at $87/month.

Advanced Conversion Features:

Exit-intent technology that detects when visitors are about to leave
A/B testing built-in to optimize your popup performance automatically
Advanced targeting based on pages visited, referral source, and behavior
Smart tags for personalized messaging based on visitor location/device
MonsterInsights integration for detailed conversion analytics

Best For: Serious marketers and businesses generating $10K+ monthly revenue who need maximum conversion rates.

Why I Recommend This: After testing 50+ popup plugins, OptinMonster consistently delivers 3-5x higher conversion rates than competitors. The exit-intent technology alone has saved thousands of would-be lost visitors for my clients.

Pricing: Basic ($21/month), Pro ($87/month), Growth ($174/month)

→ Try OptinMonster Free for 14 Days (30-day money-back guarantee)

When NOT to Choose OptinMonster:

Your monthly revenue is under $5,000
You need just basic popup functionality
You’re looking for a one-time purchase option
Your traffic is under 10,000 monthly visitors

2. Popup Maker – The Free Powerhouse

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 340% | Price: Free + Premium Extensions

Why Popup Maker ranks #2 despite being free: Unlike many plugins that cap the number of popups on their free plan, Popup Maker lets you create as many popups as you want. This makes it perfect for testing and experimentation.

Core WordPress Features:

Unlimited popups with professional templates
Exit-intent detection (premium extension)
Advanced targeting and conditions
A/B testing capabilities (premium)
WooCommerce integration for cart abandonment

Best For: WordPress users who want professional popup functionality without monthly fees.

Why I Recommend This: The free version handles 90% of what most websites need. You can always upgrade specific features as your business grows, making it incredibly cost-effective.

Pricing: Free core plugin, premium extensions $29-99/year each

→ Download Popup Maker Free (Start with unlimited popups today)

3. TrustPulse – The Social Proof Specialist

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 15% additional boost | Starting Price: $9/month

Why TrustPulse ranks #3 for specialized use: The pricing of TrustPulse starts from $9 to $50 per month when billed annually. It specializes in social proof popups that build trust and create urgency.

Social Proof Features:

Real-time activity notifications (recent purchases, signups)
Live visitor count displays
Recent customer reviews and testimonials
Geographic-based social proof messaging
Integration with WooCommerce, Easy Digital Downloads

Best For: E-commerce stores and service businesses that need to build trust and create buying urgency.

Why I Recommend This: Social proof popups work differently than traditional opt-ins. They build credibility throughout the browsing experience, leading to higher overall conversion rates.

Pricing: Basic ($9/month), Plus ($29/month), Professional ($50/month)

→ Start TrustPulse Trial (14-day money-back guarantee)

4. Sumo – The All-in-One Marketing Suite

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 250% | Price: Free + Pro at $49/month

Why Sumo ranks #4 as a complete solution: Sumo has two plans: free and paid. The paid one costs $49/mo for 100K monthly visitors. It combines popups with heat maps, analytics, and social sharing tools.

Complete Marketing Features:

Welcome mats, scroll boxes, and smart bars
Heat map analytics to optimize placement
Social sharing buttons and analytics
Email capture with built-in analytics
Contact forms and survey tools

Best For: Small businesses wanting an all-in-one marketing toolkit rather than multiple separate plugins.

Why I Recommend This: If you need popups plus other marketing tools, Sumo provides better value than buying separate solutions. The heat map data helps optimize popup placement.

Pricing: Free (Sumo branding), Pro ($49/month for 100K visitors)

→ Try Sumo Free (Upgrade when you hit limits)

5. Ninja Popups – The Design-Focused Plugin

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 200% | Price: $24 one-time

Why Ninja Popups ranks #5 for design flexibility: It offers 100+ professional templates with extensive customization options at a one-time price point that appeals to budget-conscious users.

Design & Customization Features:

100+ pre-built popup templates
Drag-and-drop visual editor
Advanced CSS customization options
Responsive design for all devices
Integration with major email services

Best For: Designers and agencies who need extensive template variety and customization control.

Why I Recommend This: The one-time pricing makes it cost-effective for multiple client projects, and the template quality rivals premium monthly services.

Pricing: Single site ($24), Extended license ($120)

→ Get Ninja Popups (One-time payment, lifetime updates)

6. Hustle – The WPMU DEV Solution

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 180% | Price: Free + Pro ($49/month for all WPMU tools)

Why Hustle ranks #6 for WordPress purists: It’s built specifically for WordPress by WPMU DEV, ensuring perfect compatibility and regular updates with WordPress core changes.

WordPress-Native Features:

Pop-ups, slide-ins, and embedded forms
Advanced targeting and scheduling
A/B testing with detailed analytics
Integration with popular email services
Mobile-responsive design templates

Best For: WordPress professionals who prefer native solutions and already use WPMU DEV tools.

Why I Recommend This: If you’re already in the WPMU ecosystem, Hustle integrates seamlessly with other tools like Defender and Hummingbird for complete site optimization.

Pricing: Free version available, Pro ($49/month includes all WPMU DEV tools)

→ Try Hustle Free (Upgrade for advanced features)

7. ConvertPro – The Beaver Builder Partner

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 160% | Price: $99/year

Why ConvertPro ranks #7 for Beaver Builder users: It integrates perfectly with Beaver Builder and offers advanced behavioral targeting that works well for content-heavy sites.

Behavioral Targeting Features:

Time-based popup triggers
Scroll percentage triggers
Page visit count targeting
Referrer-based popups
Advanced display rules

Best For: Beaver Builder users and content marketers who need sophisticated targeting based on user behavior.

Why I Recommend This: The behavioral targeting options are more advanced than most competitors, perfect for complex content marketing funnels.

Pricing: Single site ($99/year), Unlimited sites ($199/year)

→ Get ConvertPro (30-day refund guarantee)

8. Thrive Leads – The Thrive Suite Integration

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 300% | Price: $90 one-time or $19/month

Why Thrive Leads ranks #8 for content creators: It’s designed specifically for content marketing and integrates with the complete Thrive Suite for landing pages, courses, and membership sites.

Content Marketing Features:

Content upgrades and lead magnets
SmartLinks for targeted offers
Asset delivery system
Advanced A/B testing
Detailed conversion analytics

Best For: Content creators, bloggers, and online course creators who use the Thrive ecosystem.

Why I Recommend This: If you’re building a content-based business, the integration with Thrive Architect and Thrive Quiz Builder creates powerful marketing funnels.

Pricing: Thrive Leads ($90 one-time), Thrive Suite ($19/month)

→ Get Thrive Leads (30-day guarantee)

9. Icegram – The Email Marketing Focus

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 140% | Price: Free + Premium from $97/year

Why Icegram ranks #9 for email marketers: It focuses specifically on email list building with advanced segmentation and email marketing automation features built-in.

Email Marketing Features:

Advanced subscriber segmentation
Automated email sequences
Email campaign analytics
Newsletter templates
GDPR compliance tools

Best For: Small businesses that want popup functionality combined with basic email marketing automation.

Why I Recommend This: If you don’t have an email marketing service yet, Icegram provides both popup creation and email sending in one solution.

Pricing: Free version, Express ($97/year), Pro ($147/year)

→ Try Icegram Free (Upgrade for automation)

10. PopupAlly – The Lightweight Option

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 120% | Price: Free + Pro $47

Why PopupAlly ranks #10 for simplicity: It focuses on essential popup functionality without bloating your site, making it perfect for users who want basic conversion tools.

Lightweight Features:

Fast-loading popup templates
Basic targeting options
Simple analytics
Mobile-responsive design
Email service integrations

Best For: Users who want basic popup functionality without complex features or monthly fees.

Why I Recommend This: Sometimes simple is better. PopupAlly loads fast and doesn’t slow down your site while still capturing leads effectively.

Pricing: Free version, Pro ($47 one-time)

→ Download PopupAlly (Start free, upgrade when needed)

11. WP Subscribe Pro – The Minimalist Choice

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 100% | Price: $19 one-time

Why WP Subscribe Pro ranks #11 for minimalists: It does one thing exceptionally well – email subscription popups – without unnecessary features that slow down your site.

Focused Features:

Email subscription popups only
Clean, professional templates
Basic targeting options
Lightweight code
Quick setup process

Best For: Bloggers and small sites that only need email subscription popups.

Why I Recommend This: If email subscriptions are your only goal, this plugin delivers results without complexity or ongoing costs.

Pricing: $19 one-time purchase

→ Get WP Subscribe Pro (Simple setup, immediate results)

12. Layered Popups – The Animation Specialist

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 110% | Price: $29 one-time

Why Layered Popups ranks #12 for visual appeal: It offers advanced animation and layering effects that create engaging, attention-grabbing popups for creative industries.

Visual Features:

Advanced CSS animations
Layered popup effects
Video backgrounds
Parallax scrolling effects
Custom animation timing

Best For: Creative agencies, photographers, and businesses where visual appeal is crucial for brand image.

Why I Recommend This: In creative industries, popup design quality reflects your brand. Layered Popups creates memorable experiences that standard popups can’t match.

Pricing: $29 one-time purchase

→ Get Layered Popups (Stand out with stunning animations)

13. Exit Intent Popup – The Exit-Focus Plugin

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 90% | Price: Free + Pro $29

Why Exit Intent Popup ranks #13 for specific functionality: It specializes entirely in exit-intent detection, making it perfect for users who only need this one crucial feature.

Exit-Intent Features:

Advanced mouse-tracking algorithms
Mobile exit detection
Delay options and frequency capping
Basic template selection
Simple analytics

Best For: E-commerce stores that primarily need cart abandonment recovery through exit-intent detection.

Why I Recommend This: If exit-intent is your primary concern and you don’t need other popup types, this specialized plugin delivers focused results.

Pricing: Free version, Pro ($29 one-time)

→ Try Exit Intent Popup (Focus on what matters most)

14. Mailchimp for WooCommerce – The E-commerce Integration

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 85% | Price: Free

Why Mailchimp for WooCommerce ranks #14 for e-commerce: It provides seamless integration between WooCommerce and Mailchimp with popup functionality designed specifically for online stores.

E-commerce Features:

Product recommendation popups
Cart abandonment recovery
Customer segmentation based on purchase history
Automated email sequences
Revenue tracking

Best For: WooCommerce stores already using Mailchimp for email marketing.

Why I Recommend This: The tight integration means your popup data automatically segments customers for targeted email campaigns, creating a complete marketing system.

Pricing: Free (requires Mailchimp account)

→ Install Mailchimp for WooCommerce (Perfect for existing Mailchimp users)

15. Bloom – The Elegant Themes Solution

Conversion Rate Increase: Up to 75% | Price: $89/year (includes all Elegant Themes)

Why Bloom ranks #15 for Elegant Themes users: It integrates perfectly with Divi and other Elegant Themes products, providing consistent design and functionality across your site.

Design Integration Features:

Perfect Divi theme integration
Elegant design templates
Advanced form styling options
Consistent branding across site
Theme-matched animations

Best For: Divi users and Elegant Themes customers who want seamless design integration.

Why I Recommend This: If you’re already using Divi, Bloom ensures your popups match your site’s design perfectly without additional customization work.

Pricing: $89/year (includes all Elegant Themes products)

→ Get Bloom with Elegant Themes (Complete design system)

Performance Comparison Table

Plugin	Avg. Conversion Increase	Starting Price	Best For	Key Strength
OptinMonster	Up to 785%	$21/month	High-traffic sites	Advanced targeting
Popup Maker	Up to 340%	Free	WordPress users	Unlimited free popups
TrustPulse	Up to 15% boost	$9/month	E-commerce	Social proof
Sumo	Up to 250%	Free/$49/month	Small business	All-in-one toolkit
Ninja Popups	Up to 200%	$24 one-time	Designers	Template variety
Hustle	Up to 180%	Free/$49/month	WPMU users	WordPress native
ConvertPro	Up to 160%	$99/year	Beaver Builder	Behavioral targeting
Thrive Leads	Up to 300%	$90 one-time	Content creators	Content upgrades

Strategic Plugin Selection Guide

For New Websites: Start with Popup Maker

Zero monthly costs while you build your audience
Unlimited popups for testing different approaches
Upgrade to premium features as your traffic grows
Perfect for validating your popup strategy before investing

For E-commerce Stores: Choose OptinMonster + TrustPulse

OptinMonster handles cart abandonment and exit-intent
TrustPulse adds social proof to increase trust and urgency
Combined approach can increase conversions by 25-40%
ROI typically pays for itself within 30-60 days

for Content Creators: Go with Thrive Leads

Content upgrades and lead magnets built-in
Perfect integration with landing page builders
Advanced analytics for content performance
Scales with your content marketing growth

Advanced Popup Optimization Secrets

Timing Psychology That Converts:

Welcome mats work best for first-time visitors (300-600% increase)
Exit-intent triggers should activate after 30+ seconds on page
Scroll-based popups perform best at 50-70% page completion
Time-based delays of 15-30 seconds optimize for engagement vs annoyance

Mobile-Specific Optimizations:

Fullscreen mobile popups convert 40% better than scaled desktop versions
Thumb-friendly close buttons reduce abandonment by 25%
Single-field email capture outperforms multi-field by 120% on mobile
Slide-in notifications work better than traditional popups on smartphones

Conversion Copy Formulas:

Value proposition + urgency + social proof = highest converting combination
“Get [specific benefit] in [timeframe]” outperforms vague promises by 200%
Numbers and percentages increase credibility (“Join 50,000+ subscribers”)
Action words like “Download,” “Access,” “Unlock” convert better than “Subscribe”

Critical Popup Mistakes That Kill Conversions

Mistake #1: Showing Popups Too Quickly Most sites trigger popups within 5-10 seconds, which feels pushy and increases bounce rates by 35%. Users need time to engage with your content before being interrupted. Optimal timing is 30-60 seconds or based on scroll behavior.

Mistake #2: Using Generic “Subscribe to Newsletter” Copy Generic subscription offers convert at 2-3%, while specific value propositions (“Get our 5-day email course on Instagram growth”) convert at 8-12%. Always lead with the benefit, not the action.

Mistake #3: Ignoring Mobile User Experience
60% of website traffic is mobile, but many popups aren’t optimized for touch interfaces. Tiny close buttons, difficult form filling, and poor responsive design can reduce mobile conversions by 80%.

Mistake #4: Not Testing Different Popup Types Exit-intent works great for desktop but poorly on mobile. Scroll-based triggers work well for content sites but poorly for e-commerce. Always test multiple trigger types for your specific audience and content type.

Mistake #5: Showing the Same Popup to Returning Visitors Showing subscription popups to existing subscribers creates poor user experience. Use smart targeting to show different offers to returning visitors, such as product recommendations or premium content upgrades.

Essential Tools and Resources

Popup Design Tools:

Canva – Create professional popup graphics and backgrounds
Unsplash – High-quality free images for popup backgrounds
Adobe Color – Generate cohesive color schemes for your popups

Email Marketing Services (High Conversion Integrations):

ConvertKit – Best for creators and bloggers (14-day free trial)
ActiveCampaign – Advanced automation and segmentation ($9/month)
Mailchimp – Free up to 2,000 subscribers with basic features

Analytics and Testing:

Google Analytics – Track popup conversion goals and user behavior
Hotjar – Heat maps show where users engage with your popups
OptinMonster – Built-in A/B testing for popup optimization

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What’s the difference between free and premium popup plugins?

Free popup plugins typically offer basic functionality like simple popups and basic email integrations. Premium plugins add advanced features like exit-intent detection, behavioral targeting, A/B testing, detailed analytics, and priority support. For businesses generating over $5,000 monthly revenue, premium plugins usually pay for themselves within 30-60 days through increased conversions.

Q: Which popup plugin works best for WooCommerce stores?

OptinMonster offers the most comprehensive e-commerce features including cart abandonment recovery, product-specific popups, and purchase behavior targeting. For budget-conscious stores, Popup Maker’s WooCommerce integration provides solid functionality for free. TrustPulse adds valuable social proof specifically for e-commerce conversion optimization.

Q: How much should I expect to pay for a good popup plugin?

Free options like Popup Maker handle basic needs effectively. For advanced features, expect $20-90 monthly for cloud-based solutions like OptinMonster, or $50-200 annually for WordPress plugins like ConvertPro. The investment typically returns 3-10x through increased conversions within 2-3 months.

Q: Are popup plugins difficult to set up for beginners?

Most modern popup plugins offer drag-and-drop builders and pre-designed templates, making setup possible for beginners within 1-2 hours. Popup Maker and Sumo are particularly beginner-friendly. More advanced plugins like OptinMonster may require 3-4 hours for full optimization but offer step-by-step guidance.

Q: Can popup plugins slow down my website?

Well-coded plugins like OptinMonster and Popup Maker have minimal impact on site speed (typically 0.1-0.3 seconds). Avoid plugins with poor reviews mentioning speed issues. Always test your site speed before and after installation using tools like GTmetrix or Google PageSpeed Insights.

Q: How quickly will I see results from popup plugins?

Most websites see immediate results within 24-48 hours of installation. Initial conversion rates of 2-5% are typical, with optimization improving rates to 8-15% over 2-4 weeks. E-commerce sites often see cart abandonment recovery within the first week, while content sites may need 1-2 weeks to optimize timing and messaging.

Q: Should I use multiple popup types on the same page?

Generally no – multiple popups create poor user experience and can reduce overall conversions. Focus on one well-optimized popup per page. The exception is combining different popup types (exit-intent + scroll-based) with smart targeting to ensure users only see one popup per visit.

Q: What popup conversion rate should I expect?

Industry averages range from 2-4% for basic popups, but well-optimized popups achieve 8-15% conversion rates. Exit-intent popups typically convert at 4-8%, while welcome mats can achieve 15-25%. Your specific rate depends on traffic quality, offer value, and optimization efforts.

Q: Do popup plugins work with all email marketing services?

Most premium plugins integrate with 30+ email services including Mailchimp, ConvertKit, ActiveCampaign, and AWeber. Free plugins typically support 5-10 major services. Always verify integration with your specific email service before purchasing. Zapier integration expands compatibility to hundreds of additional services.

Ready to Boost Your Conversions?

Popup plugins aren’t just about capturing emails – they’re about maximizing every visitor’s potential value. When implemented strategically, they can transform casual browsers into engaged subscribers, reduce cart abandonment, and significantly increase your website’s revenue per visitor.

Your Implementation Roadmap:

Choose your plugin based on your budget and feature needs (start with our top 3 recommendations)
Set up exit-intent detection to capture abandoning visitors first (highest ROI quick win)
Create your first welcome mat for homepage visitors with a valuable lead magnet
Test different timing triggers over 2-3 weeks to optimize for your audience
Add social proof elements if you’re e-commerce to build trust and urgency

Ready to Get Started? OptinMonster delivers the highest conversion rates and you’ll see results within 48 hours of setup.

→ Start Your OptinMonster Free Trial (Transform visitors into customers with 14-day free trial)

Share this Article